To invite a close-up magician to your home or event is to put the theatrical phrase “suspend your disbelief” under a microscope.
A theatre audience looking at a stage all unconsciously accept the artificiality of a scene, but allow themselves to react emotionally as if it were absolutely true. Even if the suspension is not quite reached, social etiquette prevents the unimaginative from blurting out “This isn’t real!” to the rest of the enraptured crowd.
Yet, in a situation where the performer is an arm’s length away from the spectator and has just demonstrated something that is “impossible”, conventions change. We somehow find it far more acceptable to verbally call into question whether the man in front of you has just broken the laws of physics.
From my experience, this is still a rare event. I sense that there is always small percentage of my audience discretely trying to reason out a method to the impossible stories that I tell. However, the majority will enjoy themselves by allowing their disbelief to take them to a place of wonder.
Which is all very well, until the magician makes a mistake.
One of the most frequent questions I am asked is “What happens when it goes wrong?” There are two answers. And then an interesting epilogue.
Firstly, The second rule of performing magic states that you should never demonstrate a trick twice to the same audience. On second viewing, since the surprise is already revealed, it allows for the eagle-eyed to concentrate on all the moments that a magician tries to avoid you noticing. The other upside of an audience only witnessing one performance is particularly sneaky. The lack of foreknowledge of how the story ends allows a magician to change a trick mid performance. If they are experienced, the audience need never know.
People are surprised when I tell them that tricks “go wrong” at least once a night. Props that are meant to be handled dextrously, end up all over the floor. Maybe I feign to lose a card in the pack, but then a lapse of concentration on my part means that is out of my control.
You are definitely dealing with an amateur if when things go off piste the performer reacts as if he is in trouble. When the coins bounce off the floor or the magician loses his concentration on the pack, only an idiot would throw up his hands and blurt out. “Oh hell! That’s gone wrong.”
The well-versed magician will have enough experience to roll with the punches and phoenix-like create something magical out of the ashes of most collapses. It will involve them twisting the story that they are spinning in mid-telling. It is usually not quite as satisfying as the effect that they had planned in the first place. But my safety net becomes the certain knowledge that the audience does not know what is coming.
On a positive note, perhaps a trick “goes wrong” because my volunteer does something completely unexpected. They may make a wildly unusual choice or reveal some unique quirk or fact about themselves that I can weave into a trick that is already underway.
Therefore, if the performer has enough style, they can get to the end of a story and viewers will never suspect that there was a seismic movement in the middle of the narrative that was necessitated by something that occurred after we had started. Personally, I do this far more than my calm, gentlemanly exterior would ever display.
The second, and far more damaging, but rare, scenario is that some moments just go wildly awry and there is no rescue available. I am proud to think that I can salvage many situations and the spectators will only having a vague inkling that something was not quite perfect. However, some effects are utterly lost. This often occurs when two minor mistakes follow each other in quick succession. The other big spanner in the works is when something that should be hidden is very obviously, and suddenly, in full view.
In this moment of extremis, the only wise thing to do is admit that disaster has struck. Most audiences will be kind and sympathetic. Yes, their suspension of disbelief has just come crashing to the floor, but to plough on regardless as a massive, hitherto unseen jumbo coin spirals noisily onto the parquet floor is just insulting everyone’s intelligence.
The wise magician, dying inside with embarrassment will carry on until the big reveal is supposed to happen, even though he knows that it never will, in order to retain some sort of mystery. But it is best to admit failure, and say, “That didn’t work, did it!?”, do your best to smile about it, and offer them something better. However, I am not surprised in that situation, if they politely decline.
The only sting in the tail to this apparent honesty, is that I am rarely believed. On the odd occasion when things cannot be salvaged and I have had to abandon all hopes of an exciting finale, people wink knowingly at me. The refuse to accept my incompetence and I gather a knot of people surround me saying “But it hasn’t really gone wrong, has it?”, “this is all part of the trick”, “Just you wait, it will be under his hat all the time.”
When you spend an entire career being economical with the truth as to what your performance entails, it is only logical that when you are less than magic and openly admit it, you are doubted. This is exacerbated by the number of effects that magicians perform where something appears to go off script half way through a trick, but is actually part of the planned narrative. Magicians cry wolf frequently, so they should not be surprised that when the wolf actually arrives, they are treated very sceptically.
I suppose I should be grateful. Most audiences either never know things have gone wrong, or if they do, they refuse to believe it.
Photo credit @ianscottphoto